This is one of those questions where the best answer is, it depends! It depends on your wants and needs. Both fuels come in lots of traditional and linear sizes. Both have several media options for a unique and customized look. But, are you looking for much heat? If the answer is yes, go with gas.
If space limitations and/or venting issues make the project difficult, an electric fireplace would be a great choice. If a little supplemental heat in the room is all you’re after, go electric. Maybe you would like to enjoy the flames and lighting effects year-round. If so, operating an electric without the heat option will work out well.
If you want to use some zone heating techniques and stay comfortable in those two or three rooms of the house where you spend most of your time, a gas fireplace would be a solid option.
Heat, price and installation details are the three main variables to consider when contemplating an electric fireplace vs. a gas unit.
Ridgefield, CTYankee Doodle, Inc. 71 Ethan Allen Highway Ridgefield, CT 06877 |  | Visit Store Page |
Bellmore, NYCostello's Bellmore Hot Tub 5135 Merrick Road Bellmore, NY 11762 | | |
Carmel, NYBest in Backyards 30 Commerce Dr Carmel, NY 10512 | | |
Clifton Park, NYMatchless Stove & Chimney 1581 State Route 9 Clifton Park, NY 12065 | | |
Findley Lake, NYMatters of The Hearth, Inc. 2842 Route 426 Findley Lake, NY 14736 |  | Visit Store Page |
Glenmont, NYMatchless Stove & Chimney 693 US Route 9W Glenmont, NY 12077 | | |
Holtsville, NYOcean Stone & Fireplace 180 Long Island Ave Holtsville, NY 11742 | | |
Island Park, NYCostello's Island Park Hot Tub Showroom 3965 Long Beach Road Island Park, NY 11558 | | |
Mahopac, NYBest in Backyards 119 US-6 Mahopac, NY 10541 | | |
Marathon, NYPapa Bear's Riverside Stoves 96 Cortland Street Marathon, NY 13803 |  | Visit Store Page |
Maspeth, NYNYC Fireplaces & Outdoor Kitchens LLC 5830 Maspeth Ave Maspeth, NY 11378 |  | Visit Store Page |
New Windsor, NYBest in Backyards 432 Temple Hill Rd New Windsor, NY 12553 | | |
Plattsburgh, NYThe Hearthside Shoppe 1024 Military Turnpike Plattsburgh, NY 12901 | | |
Smithtown, NYCostello's Smithtown Hot Tub 602 Smithtown Bypass Smithtown, NY 11787 | | |
Syracuse, NYHearth and Home of Syracuse 6701 Manlius Center Rd Syracuse, NY 13057 |  | Visit Store Page |
Utica, NYThe Hearth Shop @ Universal Hearth Stores Inc. 1420 Champlin Ave Utica, NY 13502 | | |
Williamsville, NYAmerican Eagle Fireplace LLC 8455 Main Street Williamsville, NY 14221 | | |
Barre, VTChimney Sweep Fireplace Shop 1284 US Rte, 302 Ste 10 Barre, VT 05641-2317 |  | Visit Store Page |
Bennington, VTFriends of The Sun 126 Hicks Avenue Bennington, VT 05201 |  | Visit Store Page |
Manchester, VTFriends of The Sun 159 Depot Street Manchester, VT 05255 |  | Visit Store Page |
Shelburne, VTChimney Sweep Fireplace Shop 3113 Shelburne Road Shelburne, VT 05482 |  | Visit Store Page |