The straight answer is yes, and it is true in every Province. But what are the requirements?
First, let’s talk about the regulations in place and upcoming ones.
What is mostly known as a regulation on the Market is the EPA Certification. The EPA is the Environmental Protection Agency in the USA. The EPA has established a regulation to limit the amount of particulates that each wood fireplace can emit up through its chimney. As of May 2019, the limit in the USA is set at 4.5g/hr. On May 15th 2020, the new limit will be set at 2 g/hr and 2.5g/hr depending on the testing protocol being used by manufacturers.
In Canada, we have our own standard as well. It is called CSA B-415. That standard limits the particulates emissions to 4.5g/hr. That standard was established to somewhat mirror the American one, with enhancements to include warm air wood furnaces. (who had not been included in the American EPA) There is no timetable as to when and if CSA B415.1 will be mirroring the new limits of the EPA.
What about my Province?
In Canada, each Province is free to implement its own limits on wood stove emissions. They can elect not to regulate or to choose between the EPA limits or the CSA B415 limits or use both.
To help out in seeing what is the state of the affairs for each Province, HPBA Canada has sorted this out for the whole industry. Here’s the chart as set by HPBA Canada:
How do I tell if the stove I am about to buy is truly approved?
On the certification label, it will state if the stove or fireplace is EPA approved or CSA B415 approved. There is also a list of stoves and fireplaces that are approved for Canada. This list is provided by a Certification Agency. Here’s the link to the official list of CAS B415 approved fireplaces and stoves. https://www.polytests.com/registry/#
The USA EPA publishes a list of approved wood and pellet stoves. Click here to look at the current list. Please note that all stoves on this list are approved for use throughout Canada. In the following provinces, starting May 15th 2020, only ones that are NSPS 2020 Compliant will be authorized to be sold:
- British Columbia
- Nova Scotia
- New Foundland & Labrador
The other Provinces will continue to approve stoves with emissions up to 4.5g/hr beyond 2020.
Why does the certification label state that ‘It cannot be sold past May 15th 2020’?
This statement does not apply to Canada. It has been mandated by the US EPA and it applies to the United States only. The whole industry recognizes it is rather confusing from a Canadian stand point, but the statement cannot be removed for now. Industry stakeholders are working with the EPA to have a mention that this applies only to the USA.
What about Montreal? Does it not have its own regulation on wood heating?
Yes it does. Montreal has a law that limits the use of wood burning appliances. They have to be under 2.5g/hr in particulate emissions. These appliances must be under 2.5g/hr and either EPA Certified (on the EPA list above) or CSA B415 Approved. (Polytest list)
For more details on the cities and suburbs around Montreal, visit the HPBAC Website: http://hpbacanada.org/consumer-resources/wood-burning-in-canada/.
If you want to learn more on the subject of the regulation in Montreal, we have the following report that is very well documented: https://welovefire.com/stoves/new-epa-standard-for-wood-heating-appliances-how-are-montreal-canada-and-the-united-states-prepared/
Ultimately, is wood heating good for the environment?
Yes it is. There are many debates on the subject. Some folks who are sincere in their effort will claim wood smoke is detrimental to our health. In reality, exposing ourselves directly to smoke from any source is not good for the health. But, we have to look at it from a global standpoint.
To operate our cars, our heating and air conditioning, lighting, etc, we need energy. Energy comes from burning fossil fuels, shale oil and gas, coal, nuclear, wood, solar and hydro. The global effort is to reduce the footprint, the emissions while increasing efficiency. Every industry has done a tremendous job in that regard, including wood heating. Wood stoves emissions from 20 years ago are now reduced by over 90% and efficiency has increased over 30% on average. That is a spectacular improvement!
On the global footprint, firewood is locally sourced, so there is less transportation involved compared to other energy sources. Compared to electricity transportation where over 70% is wasted with power lines emitting and releasing electricity, wood fares better. Wood is also carbon neutral. It is a natural resource that is renewed within 30 to 70 years which is a very short span when compared to fossil fuels. Wood heat produces ashes as a residual and it is good for the environment. Compared to nuclear waste, the disposal of solar panels and batteries, wood is again much better for the environment on the long-term spectrum.
We have to agree, that there is always an angle on things. There will always be opposers to any technology and there will be promoters as well. We believe wood heating serves a purpose of enjoyment, independence, and savings for homeowners. That is essentially why we love wood heat. We’re happy to see the wood fireplace manufacturers invest in improving the technology by lowering emissions and increasing efficiency. They are playing a key role in keeping the air we breathe clean and healthy!